The List
I think the real explaination necessary here is, "Where the heck do you find the time for all this anime?!" And well, I don't really have an answer for that.
Total Unique Titles: ~152
- Review post available
Random Facts
First series ever seen: Naruto (2003 or 2004 ish?)
Longest series seen: Detective Conan (470+)
Favorite Characters (male/female): Morita Shinobu (Honey and Clover) / Kino (Kino's Journey)
Favorite Couple: Syaoran X Sakura (Cardcaptor Sakura, Tsubasa Chronicle)
Favorite Subber: Kaizoku-Fansubs
Goal: Watch an anime for every letter of the alphabet.
Series and their Movies, OVAs, and Specials
Azumanga Daioh - The Very Short Movie
Azumanga Web Daioh (ONA)
Bakuretsu Tenshi
Bartender
Kaleido Star OVA 1 - New Wings Extra Stage
Kaleido Star OVA 2 - Legend of Phoenix ~Layla Hamilton Story~
Kaleido Star OVA 3 - It's Good! Goood!!
Kenran Butoh Sai: The Mars Daybreak
Kiddy Grade
Kimi ga Nozomu Eien
Kimi ga Nozomu Eien Gaiden (OVA)
Kino no Tabi - the Beautiful World -
Kino no Tabi: Tower Country (OVA)
Kino no Tabi -life goes on- (Movie)
Kino no Tabi - the Beautiful World - Byouki no Kuni -For You- (Movie 2)
Kono Minikuku mo Utsukushii Sekai
Last Exile
Law of Ueki, The
Love Hina
Love Hina Again (OVA)
Love Hina Christmas Special
Love Hina Spring Special
Loveless
Madlax
Mai-HiME
Mai-Otome
Paradise Kiss
Peacemaker Kurogane
Piano
Portrait de Petit Cossette, Le (OVA)
Prince of Tennis
Prince of Tennis OVA 1: A Day on Survival Mountain
Prince of Tennis: The Two Samurai, The First Game (Movie)
Prince of Tennis: Atobe Kara no Okurimono (Short)
Prince of Tennis OVA 2: The National Tournament
Prince of Tennis OVA 3: The National Tournament Semifinal
Ragnarok the Animation
RahXephon
RahXephon OVA Interlude: Her and Herself/Thatness and Thereness
RahXephon Tagen Hensoukyoku (Movie)
Read or Die
Read or Die OVA
REC
Romeo x Juliet
Rozen Maiden
Rurouni Kenshin
Rurouni Kenshin OVA 1 - Reminiscence
Rurouni Kenshin OVA 2 - Seisouhen
Rurouni Kenshin: Requiem for the Restoration Royalists (Movie)
SaiKano
SaiKano OVA - Another Love Song
Saiunkoku Monogatari
Anime Movies
Anime Shorts, OVAs, ONAs, Specials
Top 10 Anime Series (Overall):
Top 5 Worst Series (Overall):
To be fair, I'm only listing the ones I've finished. Boring, annoying, or just plain bad.
Top 5 Series (Story/Plot):
Interesting, understandable, clever, and well thought-out storylines with a great plot.
Top 5 Series (Comedy):
You know, the ones that make you laugh out loud. Also great rewatch value.
Top 5 Series (Animated Action):
Great fully animated fight scenes, less scattered bodies due to random crazy slashing.
Top 5 Series (Sports):
By sports, I mean the typical plot style of underdog somehow manages to be top of their sport/niche
due to some odd mixture of innate talent, hard work, and guts.
Top 5 Series (Artsy Style):
Eye candy and careful attention towards creating a unique artsy style.

Top 5 Hottest Anime Guys:
See the trend? Hehe. Yey for tall dark and handsome!

** See my ratings for each anime on: 
Good Anime Recommendations
(GAR Stars!)
Long:
(Hunter X Hunter, Full Moon wo Sagashite, Chobits, DNA2, Ah! My Goddess, Spiral, Hikaru no Go, Samurai Deeper Kyo, Tsubasa Chronicle)
Christina:
(Prince of Tennis, Chrno Crusade, One Piece, Kenran Butoh Sai, Samurai Champloo, Gankutsuou, Gunslinger Girl, Monster)
Eli:
(Getbackers, Full Metal Panic, Onegai Teacher, Great Teacher Onizuka, Love Hina, Mai HiME, Yakitate!! Japan, Detective Academy Q)
Thomas:
(Tonari no Totoro, Grave of the Fireflies, Samurai7, Whispers of the Heart, Bleach, Elfen Lied)
Hobbit:
(Hajime no Ippo, Last Exile, Beck, School Rumble, The Law of Ueki)
Kim:
(Trigun, Spirited Away, Noir, Honey and Clover, Death Note)
Mikey:
(Princess Mononoke, Cowboy Bebop, Voices of a Distant Star)
Esther:
(Fruits Basket, His and Her Circumstances, Paradise Kiss)
Chris:
(Naruto, Rurouni Kenshin)
Daniel:
(Gundam SEED, Kaleido Star)